Who Thinks What

You are currently viewing page 115 of comments. Go to the first page

George McDonald

28th June 2024

TCO2 Testing – SA Racing’s Road To Damascus Moment

Frankie we follow your postings knowing you have the inside track in horse racing whether it is South Central or North
But what is meant by the Tiger Woods

Reply

Gregg Clarke

28th June 2024

The Real Stars Of Ascot

"...while Galileo’s triple Gr1 winning daughter Rhododendron (a full-sister to the South African based sire Flying The Flag) is the dam of Wednesday’s Gr1 Prince Of Wales’s Stakes winner Auguste Rodin."

I remain floored that SA has maintained its lack of appetitite for FLYING THE FLAG.

If it can be accepted that a good horse may lose its form but never its class, its astounding that breeders and buyers, who drive breeding decisions ultimately, continue to shun this magnificent sire bloodline.

Just maybe they will re-think their view come July 6th. One can only hope that FLAG MAN earns his sire some respect for what courses through his

Reply

Warren Jacobs

28th June 2024

TCO2 Testing – SA Racing’s Road To Damascus Moment

Can all those you are in favour of TCO2 testing in it's current format please explain why the number of scratchings are increasing instead of decreasing? Surely logic dictates that "cheating" trainers, now aware of the testing would decrease or eliminate their "milkshaking" practices not increase it. Then why the continual spike in positives?
Just

Reply

Tyrone Bougaard

28th June 2024

Jockey Sandile Khathi Suspended

TCO2 even hit the jockeys

Reply

Warren Jacobs

28th June 2024

TCO2 Testing – SA Racing’s Road To Damascus Moment

Sorry to say, but it seems that you are not well informed on potential causes of heightened TCO2 levels, much like the NHA...but that explains your support of them.
Testing in its current form is not levelling playing fields, it's killing the sport for disillusioned punters, owners and trainers. I wait with bated breath (and absolute fear) to see what happens on July

Reply

Selwyn Elk

28th June 2024

TCO2 Testing – SA Racing’s Road To Damascus Moment

Hi Donald, if you want to know the ball by ball lead up to the Sea Cottage shooting , give me a call, I was there when the seed was planted at a venue called The Monaco Club, seems like

Reply

Warren Jacobs

28th June 2024

TCO2 Testing – SA Racing’s Road To Damascus Moment

The obvious reason for the NHA not taking action against trainers is that they themselves are uncertain as to what causes the heightened TCO2 levels. Which it turn means that they themselves don't trust their own testing processes 100%. Why then implement the test when you are not confident of what the results are telling you?
This smacks of impulsive decision making, power play, seeking relevance and in my opinion stemmed from personal agendas/vendettas against certain trainers by certain people within the NHA

Reply

Frankie Zackey

28th June 2024

TCO2 Testing – SA Racing’s Road To Damascus Moment

Frankie Zackey... One needs to ask themselves do all trainers train their horses exactly the same ? slightly different or completely different ? My opinion,, no trainer trains the same... How many trainers give horse's a run to bring them on for their next run ? My opinion,, there are many trainers,, so I'm assuming these horses will never get a positive reading... How many trainers give horses runs to get their merit ratings down ? MY opinion,,many trainers,, so again I'm assuming these horses will never get a positive reading... How many trainers are there that are soft on their horse's ? My opinion a good few,, so I'm assuming again you'll never see a positive reading.. It's no secret when it comes to 1st timers,, that there's a good few trainers that are soft on their babies 1st time out or that are coming back from a layoff,,so again I'm assuming that these horses will never be effected by the TC02 readings... How many trainers feed differently ? A good few...How many trainers use the same feed ? a good few...How many trainers can afford good bedding throughout the month ? I'm assuming not too many,, and medication,,vitamins and whatever else on their horses ? Unfortunately many trainers are financially (stuffed) so many need to stretch feed,, bedding and giving vitamins on a regular basis,, as we know this could be costly,, so I'm not sure how many can afford this..How many times have you heard of trainers feed and bedding going missing ? I've heard of a good few... read more

Michael Jacobs

28th June 2024

The Durban July – 21st Century Magic

As the Hollywoodbets Durban July day looms, the TCO2 crisis is also hanging like a dark cloud over the industry, surely a quick fix solution is needed for the day to avert international embarrassment, potential protests and riot and overall dampener on the day.

The NHA should announce a stop gap measure for the day. The top 5 finishers in every race will be tested immediately after the running of each race. Any horse found over the limit should be immediately disqualified but the result will stand for payout purposes. Additional punitive measures should include forfeiture of any stakes money, and a suspension for the horse. A fine for the trainer could also apply.

This could be enough of a deterant for would be "milkshakers" to cease and desist any

Reply

Michael Jacobs

28th June 2024

Fairview – R3 Million Pick 6 Pool Expected Today

What's with S'manga Khumalo giving long lectures in the winning enclosure during every winning interview?! Not a word before the race, but then a 5 to 10 minute speech after the

Reply

Harold Narainsamy

28th June 2024

Flag Man Catches Eye At Big Race Gallops

Were the ancestors any good at backing winners when they were

Reply

George McDonald

28th June 2024

The Durban July – 21st Century Magic

According to some, after checking the photo finish,the judges took 12 minutes to finally declare El Picha the winner of the 2000 July
Officially the time was given as 7 minutes.
And after that we were told by the powers that be that the days of a deadheat in South African horse racing was over/no more.
We were told the judges could separate horses by the thickness of cigarette paper using new equipment
Seems the new equipment was a

Reply

Livingstone Mpongo

28th June 2024

Jockey Sandile Khathi Suspended

Very dangerous, indeed. Haven't checked if he has rides in the Durban July. If so, I suppose he misses out. Very disappointing from an otherwise good

Reply

Cecil Pienaar

28th June 2024

Jockey Sandile Khathi Suspended

🤭 Sandile, jou stout blixem !

Drink en bestuur, hoop jy het Public transport gebruik !

Enjoy the 14 days off, you got off lightly.

Nee man, this is disappointing, rides are scarce in PE

Reply

Basie viljoen

28th June 2024

TCO2 Testing – SA Racing’s Road To Damascus Moment

Plz name

Reply

Richard Jones

28th June 2024

Flag Man Catches Eye At Big Race Gallops

Having just watched the post-gallops interviews I have to question why Justin Snaith and Andre Nel were nastily critical of local jockeys. I do follow racing worldwide, and despite the win against a very weak Met field, in my mind Daniel Muscutt is no better than at least seven or eight local jocks. If he finishes in the top 10 with Double Superlative, I'll be very surprised! Zac Lloyd is a budding superstar and would've been a better choice if they were looking overseas for better jockeys.
In fact, Snaith was on the defensive and also having a go at other trainers who were galloping their July charges against "lead horses". Even with the weight advantage and Fourie, I'm confident none of his three will beat Flag

Reply

Donald Bradshaw

28th June 2024

TCO2 Testing – SA Racing’s Road To Damascus Moment

All good George , sad that the Sea Cottage incident has never been completely understood and with the years running along at a good click it appears the narrative will pass into history with just the gist of the exact facts as they unfolded over those two months in 1966 before that July Handicap ironically won by his stablemate Java Head

Reply

Richard Jones

28th June 2024

The Durban July – 21st Century Magic

Even with the dark TCO2 cloud hanging over this year's event, one can't shake off five decades of habit and not be excited about the July.
My only hope is that it is incident

Reply

Debby Smith

28th June 2024

Jockey Sandile Khathi Suspended

Imagine that a semi drunk jockey on a racing horse eish that's dangerous

Reply

Michael Jacobs

28th June 2024

Jockey Sandile Khathi Suspended

Was Mr Khathi not the jockey who was penalized for presenting a tampered with urine sample a few months ago, for which he was given a 365 day suspended sentence? And now he has transgressed with a similar (though not exactly the same) offense again? What happens

Reply

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp

Popular Posts

The Enchanting Currency Of Fate

It is eerie to think that there would have been no Siren’s Call, Sound Of Warning, or for that matter Call To Unite, had fate not decreed that Enchanted Cove follow her dam to South Africa, and that Peter de Beyer had the foresight to return Elusive Fort back home from the States as well!

Read More »