MR Challenge (3)

Final Analysis: rating the races

Post-race analysis is the most important task a handicapper is faced with, as it sets the scene for the future.

If you introduce ‘mistakes’ into the ratings system, you’ll poison the well.

The worst crime is rating a race too high, as ratings ripple through the system and may take ages to correct, if at all.

Rating a race too low is usually easier to correct, or self-correcting, often in short time.

With that in mind, let’s look at our two races from Saturday, and see what we can make of it.

 

Turffontein race 3 – MR 95 F&M  2000m

First do the groundwork for the day as a whole, to get perspective.

Sunny & warm, with a 9-13km SW cross-headwind. No rain in the last 7 days, and 42mm irrigation during that time.

Penetrometer 21 and going posted as Good. False rail 2m out on the bend, with a 2m spur at the 500m mark.

Race-times for the day, with in brackets the average for 1000m as a guide:

R1 Maiden 1450m 89.37 (avg 61.6)
R2 Maiden 1600m 112.96 (avg 62.8)
R3 MR95f 2000m 126.47 (avg 63.3)
R4 MR73f 2000m 125.85 (avg 62.9)
R5 MR80 1200m 72.22 (avg 60.2)
R6 Cdnfm 1450m 87.14 (avg 60.1)
R7 Cdn 1450m 88.88 (avg 61.3)
R8 MR76f 1450m 88.35 (avg 60.9)
R9 MR68f 1450m 89.24 (avg 61.5)

 

“Our’ Race 3 Fillies & Mares MR 95 race stands out, but not in a positive way.

It went on average slower than the MR 73 over the same distance, and slower than a mile for Maidens!

The first question a handicapper has to ask is ‘if this race was run again would the result likely be the same’.

The answer here must be ‘no!’ – the race certainly was not a true run race and running it again would not likely give the same result.

That means that whichever way the MRs are adjusted post-race, it will be wrong.

So the right thing to do here is to be conservative and leave everything as is, with no adjustment to any of the ratings.

After all, it should not be the Official Handicapper’s responsibility if jockeys decide to mess around and turn a race into a tactical affair – so his original assessment should stand.

*******

As an aside, the two Gr2 features on the day (race 6 and race 7) shows the fillies one to have been exceptionally fast (faster on average even than the 1200m sprint race).

Given the tight finish and the much slower time of the colt’s equivalent, that possibly wasn’t a true race, so that result must be treated with caution in terms of ratings and future reliability. Sectional times for the two races might give further insight, but right now nothing is up the Tellytrack site.

 

Durbanville race 7 – Gr3 Matchem Stakes 1400m

Clear Skies, 15 – 32kph South Westerly Cross Wind. No rain during the last 7 days, and 24mm irrigation added. Penetrometer read 20 and the going was posted as Good. There was no false rail on the bend, and a 2m spur at the 500m mark coming into the straight.

Times for the day, with the average for 1000m as a guide:

R1 Maiden 1250m 74.77 (avg 59.8)
R2 Maiden 1250m 74.7 (avg 59.8)
R3 Maiden 1600m 99.28 (avg 62.0)
R4 MR 78 1600m 97.5 (avg 60.9)
R5 MR 90 1600m 96.03 (avg 60.0)
R6 Cndfm 1400m 83.6 (avg 59.7)
R7 Cnd 1400m 82.27 (avg 58.8)
R8 Maiden 1400m 84.39 (avg 60.3)

 

The Matchem Stakes was on average the fastest run race on the day, suggesting a true run race.

This wasn’t a handicap race, so we need to decide what to do with the ratings.

To make it easier to follow, we’ll take the winner at his pre-race MR and adjust the others.

  • First adjust for weight difference (2 MR points per kg), then for beaten lengths (3 MR points per length), the for weight-for-age (7kg or 14 MR points for 3yo).

The sensible adjustment would be to take seasoned 7yo sprinter Search Party as the line horse at his pre-race MR 115 and go -7 on the above raceMR calculations.

That makes the final raceMR ratings (pre-race in brackets):

  • One World 120 (127)
  • Search Party 115 (115)
  • Undercover Agent 118 (130)
  • Pleasedtomeetyou 110 (112)
  • African Warrior 114 (112)
  • New Caledonia 109 (109)
  • Sacred Arrow 107 (110)
  • Ready Steady Go 103 (105)
  • Fifty Cents 102 (105)
  • Star Chestnut 96 (109)
  • Bishop’s Bounty 95 (107)

Alternatively, Pleasedtomeetyou could be the line horse at 112, which would peg the above ratings 2 higher (and make Search Party and New Caledonia go up 2 on the pre-race MR).

What would you do?

 

Have Your Say - *Please Use Your Name & Surname

Comments Policy
The Sporting Post encourages readers to comment in the spirit of enlightening the topic being discussed, to add opinions or correct errors. All posts are accepted on the condition that the Sporting Post can at any time alter, correct or remove comments, either partially or entirely.

All posters are required to post under their actual name and surname – no anonymous posts or use of pseudonyms will be accepted. You can adjust your display name on your account page or to send corrections privately to the EditorThe Sporting Post will not publish comments submitted anonymously or under pseudonyms.

Please note that the views that are published are not necessarily those of the Sporting Post.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
40 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Share:

Facebook
WhatsApp
Twitter

Popular Posts

The Enchanting Currency Of Fate

It is eerie to think that there would have been no Siren’s Call, Sound Of Warning, or for that matter Call To Unite, had fate not decreed that Enchanted Cove follow her dam to South Africa, and that Peter de Beyer had the foresight to return Elusive Fort back home from the States as well!

Read More »